Grafton Street Pub Lake Mary Review: Ireland Without the Flight

If you’ve ever wished you could step into a proper Irish pub without booking a flight to Dublin, Grafton Street Pub in Lake Mary is about as close as it gets in Central Florida. From the gold crown over the door to the Guinness-lined walls inside, everything here is designed to transport you — and the food absolutely holds up its end. Here’s our honest review.

Location & Hours

Grafton Street Pub sits at 7055 Co Rd 46A, Lake Mary, FL 32746, right off County Road 46A near International Parkway. It’s an easy stop whether you’re local to Seminole County or passing through on I-4.

• Phone: (407) 936-3782
• Hours: Mon 3 PM–9 PM; Tue 11 AM–10 PM; Wed 11 AM–11 PM; Thu–Fri 11 AM–midnight; Sat 10:30 AM–midnight; Sun 10:30 AM–10 PM
• Price: $30 and under per OpenTable — casual dining, casual dress
• Reservations: Accepted (bookable on OpenTable)

The Decor: Straight Out of Dublin

The Irish pub atmosphere hits you before you even walk in: a big gold crown logo crowns the facade above the “GRAFTON STREET PUB” sign, and the deep green double doors with gold lettering feel imported straight from Ireland.

Inside, it’s all exposed brick, warm wood, a pressed-tin ceiling, and walls of twinkling fairy lights mixed with vintage Guinness signage. There’s even a hidden speakeasy tucked in the back for a moodier drink. Every corner is photogenic without trying too hard — it feels authentic, not theme-parky.

The Bar: An Authentic Pub Without the Flight

The bar itself is the showpiece: dark green walls, a sweeping marble counter, glowing back-bar shelves stocked floor to ceiling, crystal chandeliers, and a striking peacock artwork watching over it all. Pull up one of the green velvet stools and you could be on Grafton Street in Dublin — no passport required.

It’s a full bar with cocktails, wine, and of course a proper Guinness pour. The pub also hosts live music, has outdoor patio seating, and is dog friendly — easy to see why it’s become a neighborhood gathering spot.

What We Ate

The menu is classic Irish gastropub with some creative twists, and the presentation genuinely is a work of art.

Gourmet Grilled Cheese with Tomato Bisque ($16) — my order, and the standout. Gruyère and Irish cheddar with chili-infused honey on perfectly golden, crispy bread, paired with a rich tomato bisque topped with sour cream and toasted breadcrumbs. Comfort food elevated.

Caprese Pesto Flatbread (from $15) — my guest’s pick, topped with chicken, basil pesto, grape tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, arugula, and a balsamic reduction drizzle. Beautiful to look at, even better to eat — they were equally pleased.

We also got a look at the St. James Three-Onion Soup — beef broth, caramelized onions, and a molten cap of Gruyère and provolone. A must for soup lovers.

Elsewhere on the menu: Grafton Wings ($16), Shepherd’s Pie ($18), Fish & Chips ($19), pretzel sticks with beer cheese ($13.95), and desserts like key lime pie ($9) and New York cheesecake ($12).

Service

The staff here is genuinely warm — friendly, accommodating, and quick without ever making you feel rushed. It’s the kind of service that makes you want to come back, and online reviewers consistently rate service among the pub’s best features (4.7 on OpenTable).

Good to Know Before You Go

• Address: 7055 Co Rd 46A, Lake Mary, FL 32746
• Phone: (407) 936-3782
• Hours: Lunch through late night daily; weekend brunch from 10:30 AM
• Extras: Hidden speakeasy in the back, live music, outdoor seating, dog friendly, happy hour, takeout available
• Ratings: 4.7 on OpenTable (116+ reviews), 4.3 on Restaurantji (400 ratings)
• Tip: Evenings and weekends get busy — reservations on OpenTable are a smart move

The Honest Verdict

What we loved: the transportive Irish decor, a bar that feels straight out of Dublin, delicious food with beautiful presentation, and service that’s as friendly as it gets.

What to know going in: it’s popular, so expect a wait at peak times without a reservation. That’s really the only caveat.

Who it’s best for: date nights, groups of friends, anyone craving proper pub food, and Irish culture fans who want the atmosphere without the airfare. If you live anywhere near Lake Mary and haven’t been, fix that soon.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Grafton Street Pub located?

Grafton Street Pub is at 7055 Co Rd 46A, Lake Mary, FL 32746, near the intersection of County Road 46A and International Parkway. Call (407) 936-3782.

What are Grafton Street Pub’s hours?

Monday 3 PM–9 PM; Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM; Wednesday 11 AM–11 PM; Thursday and Friday 11 AM–midnight; Saturday 10:30 AM–midnight; Sunday 10:30 AM–10 PM. Weekend brunch starts at 10:30 AM.

What should I order at Grafton Street Pub?

Our picks: the Gourmet Grilled Cheese with tomato bisque ($16) and the Caprese Pesto Flatbread (from $15). Customer favorites also include the Shepherd’s Pie, Fish & Chips, Grafton Wings, and the St. James Three-Onion Soup.

Does Grafton Street Pub take reservations?

Yes — reservations are accepted and bookable on OpenTable. Recommended for weekend evenings.

Is there a speakeasy at Grafton Street Pub?

Yes — there’s a hidden speakeasy tucked in the back of the pub with a moodier, more intimate vibe. Ask the staff about it when you visit.